What Sets A Kansas City Strip Steak Apart From A New York One?

The Kansas City strip steak and the New York strip steak are essentially the same cut of meat, both originating from the short loin of a cow, known for their tenderness and flavor. However, subtle differences in preparation and presentation have led to distinct identities for each. The Kansas City strip is traditionally bone-in, which can enhance flavor during cooking and provide a richer taste due to the marrow and fat surrounding the bone. It often retains a section of fat along the edge, contributing to its robust flavor and juiciness. On the other hand, the New York strip is usually served boneless, offering a leaner option that still delivers a satisfying taste, though slightly less intense compared to its Kansas City counterpart. The New York strip is often trimmed more closely, presenting a more uniform, visually appealing appearance. In culinary settings, the choice between the two often comes down to personal preference. Those who enjoy the additional depth of flavor and juiciness might prefer the Kansas City version, while those seeking a more refined presentation without the bone might lean towards the New York strip. Both cuts, however, are celebrated for their rich taste and tenderness, making them staples in steakhouses across the country.
Advertisement

What sets the cuts apart

Due to their similarities, New York and Kansas City Strip steaks are best prepared using comparable cooking techniques. Both cuts come from a part of the cow that experiences minimal exercise, resulting in a more tender texture. This contrasts with tougher cuts like brisket, which require longer cooking times. Consequently, strip steaks are ideal for grilling or stovetop cooking—no need for slow cooking or braising!

Instead, you should choose a quicker cooking method at a higher temperature. Because these steaks have low fat content, they can become tough if cooked at lower temperatures or for extended periods, as there’s no fat to help maintain a tender texture. Techniques like pan searing or grilling work exceptionally well for these cuts, and you can also briefly place them in a very hot oven (around 450 degrees Fahrenheit). Aim for an internal temperature of 145 degrees Fahrenheit for a medium doneness. Remember to let the steaks rest before serving to ensure a juicier result.

A history of steaks

Although Kansas City and New York Strip steaks have names that suggest they come from different regions, they actually share a significant history linked to the renowned Delmonico's Steakhouse. This historic New York establishment, which opened its doors in 1837, is credited with introducing the culinary world to the Kansas City strip steak, which may have originally been referred to as Delmonico steak, as it was a signature dish on their menu. However, today, the KC strip and Delmonico steak are sourced from different parts of the cow. Delmonico steaks are cut from the rib section, while strips come from the short loin.

Similar to the Kansas City cut, the New York strip also has connections to Delmonico's Steakhouse. It is believed that the steak may have been created by the restaurant when the Delmonico brothers decided to cut and remove the bone from the strip at the request of customers, making it more visually appealing. The absence of the bone made the steak easier to eat, aligning it with fine dining standards. Regardless, both steaks have become staples in American cuisine and are excellent choices for any dinner menu.

Recommended

Next up

Advertisement