Agave nectar is the easiest swap
Agave is primarily recognized as the source of tequila and mezcal, but it is also widely used as a sweetener. Its nectar, commonly referred to as agave syrup, is the concentrated sap of the plant and serves as an excellent one-to-one alternative to corn syrup in many situations. With a Brix measurement ranging from approximately 65 to 79, it is comparable to corn syrup. Importantly, agave nectar has a very subtle flavor, similar to that of corn syrup, ensuring that there is no noticeable difference in the taste of your dishes.
In addition to its sweetness and flavor profile, agave nectar shares a similar thickness with corn syrup. Both are viscous yet easy to pour, making agave nectar an ideal substitute for corn syrup in ice creams, sweet sauces, and sugar pies. However, one limitation of agave nectar is that it cannot replace corn syrup in candy recipes. Due to its distinct chemical properties, agave nectar will burn before reaching the required temperature for candy-making.
Honey is a slightly sweeter substitution
While agave nectar is the closest alternative to corn syrup in many cases, it is still gaining traction and may not yet be a common item in the kitchens of many home cooks. However, honey is a staple in most U.S. households and serves as an excellent one-to-one replacement for corn syrup, though there are a few factors to consider. Honey has a Brix level of around 80, which is slightly higher than that of most corn syrups, so keep in mind that using honey could result in a sweeter outcome. The sweetness will also depend on the type of honey you choose, which introduces another consideration.
There is a wide range of honey types, each distinguished by the plants from which the bees collect their nectar. The nectar source significantly influences the honey's color, sweetness, and overall taste. When substituting honey for corn syrup, it's best to select a mild variety to closely replicate the nearly neutral flavor of corn syrup. Clover honey is an excellent option due to its light and mild profile, as is alfalfa honey. Conversely, darker varieties like buckwheat honey can overpower the other flavors in your dish. Honey is particularly effective in baked goods and beverages, but it is not suitable for candy-making due to its tendency to crystallize.
Brown rice syrup is the swap you need for candy
Candy recipes are among the most challenging to adapt when substituting corn syrup. There are few liquid sweeteners that can achieve the high temperatures needed for candy-making while also preventing crystallization. However, brown rice syrup stands out as an exception. Also referred to as rice malt syrup or maltose syrup, it has a thick, sticky consistency similar to molasses, yet it is lighter in color, resembling honey. This syrup is produced by converting rice starch into sugar and then concentrating it.
Brown rice syrup closely matches the sweetness of corn syrup, measuring at 78 degrees Brix, which is comparable to corn syrup's average of 77 degrees. Its versatility allows it to be used in nearly any recipe that requires corn syrup, including baked goods, marshmallows, and, most importantly, candy. Brown rice syrup can endure the high temperatures needed for making hard candies and effectively addresses the common issue of crystallization.
Pancake syrup beats maple syrup
Maple syrup can serve as a substitute for corn syrup if you find yourself without alternatives, but it has a thinner texture and a distinctly different taste, making it more suitable as a last resort in baking (or even better, consider using it as a vanilla replacement). A more effective option would be to use artificial maple syrup, often referred to as pancake syrup, as a direct one-to-one replacement for corn syrup. The reason pancake syrups, such as Mrs. Butterworth's and Log Cabin, are effective substitutes is that they primarily consist of corn syrup.
Most pancake syrup brands are made from a blend of corn syrup and high fructose corn syrup, giving them a similar consistency to corn syrup. However, these syrups also include artificial maple flavoring, resulting in a much bolder taste compared to the relatively mild flavor of corn syrup. They are best suited for recipes that enhance a maple flavor, such as baked goods.
Simple syrup has the most versatile flavor, but takes more work
This final option demands more effort than the others, but it yields a light, mild syrup that closely resembles the flavor of corn syrup. Simple syrup is aptly named, as it requires just sugar and water, which you boil together until the sugar fully dissolves. A typical simple syrup recipe, often used in cocktails, calls for equal parts sugar and water, but this results in a rather thin consistency. To achieve a viscosity similar to corn syrup, you'll need to increase the sugar content.
The ideal ratio for a corn syrup substitute is four parts sugar to one part water. This will create a thicker syrup and elevate the sweetness to approximately 80 degrees Brix, making it slightly sweeter than corn syrup. Nevertheless, the neutral flavor of simple syrup allows you to use it in place of corn syrup in almost any recipe without altering the flavor or texture. The only exception, as with most corn syrup alternatives, is that simple syrup is not suitable for candy-making. Since it is made from granulated sugar, it will crystallize if you try to use it for candy.
Recommended
The Underrated Pantry Ingredient Guy Fieri Never Goes Without
2 Prep Steps That Make Canned Corn Beef Taste Elevated
A Simple Rule For Buying The Best Tomatoes Out Of Season
The Luxurious Steak Upgrade Your Fettuccine Alfredo Deserves
Next up
