master-cooks | The Common Mistake That Prevents Grilled Cheese From Melting

One common mistake that prevents grilled cheese from melting properly is using the wrong type of cheese. Not all cheeses melt well, and selecting one that doesn't is a frequent error. For a perfectly melted grilled cheese, it's essential to choose cheeses known for their excellent melting properties, such as American, cheddar, mozzarella, or Gruyère. These cheeses contain the right balance of moisture and fat, allowing them to melt smoothly and evenly. Another factor to consider is the thickness of the cheese slices. Slices that are too thick may not heat all the way through before the bread becomes overly toasted or burnt. Thin, even slices help ensure that the cheese melts quickly and uniformly. Additionally, using the right amount of heat is crucial. Cooking over medium or medium-low heat allows the cheese to melt thoroughly without burning the bread. Lastly, covering the pan while cooking can trap the heat, helping the cheese melt faster. By selecting the right cheese, slicing it appropriately, and cooking at the correct temperature, you can avoid the mistake of a poorly melted grilled cheese and enjoy a gooey, satisfying sandwich.

The best cheese types for grilled cheese sandwiches

Another useful tip is to grate your cheese before putting together your sandwich. Since the pieces will be thin and uniform, they will melt faster and more evenly. Many people already have a grater at home, even if they lack a cheese slicer, making this a budget-friendly solution if you find that your grilled cheese often lacks that gooey melt.

The type of cheese you choose for your grilled cheese is also important, as hard cheeses generally don’t melt well. No matter how thinly you slice hard cheese, it won’t provide a satisfying melt, which can leave you disappointed. Some common hard cheeses to steer clear of include parmesan, aged goudas, and aged cheddars. Instead, go for softer cheeses that melt more easily and effectively. Popular choices include American, Swiss, Gruyère, Comté, Colby, Monterey Jack, young cheddars, young goudas, pepper jack, provolone, and brie. You can also experiment with combining different cheeses to enhance the flavor. Just keep in mind that this may result in a rather substantial grilled cheese, which might require a bit more care to ensure it melts properly without burning the bread.

Cooking techniques for a gooey grilled cheese

While the suggestion to use thinner cheese slices is great for a simple grilled cheese with just a couple of slices, it may not suffice for a more indulgent version. If you're aiming for a loaded grilled cheese, you might face challenges in getting the cheese to melt, even with thin or grated options. In such cases, a low and slow cooking method can be advantageous. One approach is to cook your grilled cheese on low heat on the stovetop while covering the pan with a lid. This helps retain heat, allowing the cheese to melt without burning the bread. Alternatively, you can try reverse searing your grilled cheese: start by baking it on low in the oven to achieve a gooey interior, then transfer it to a pan for a quick toast and crisp on the outside.

Even if you're not piling on the cheese, patience is key. Rushing the cooking process often leads to either burnt bread or unmelted cheese. With a little patience and the right cheese slices, you'll be on your way to crafting a delicious sandwich.

The Common Mistake That Prevents Grilled Cheese From Melting

The best cheese types for grilled cheese sandwiches

Cooking techniques for a gooey grilled cheese

Recommended

Next up