master-cooks | The Addition That Sets Hoosier Chili Apart From The Rest

Hoosier chili is a unique take on the beloved comfort food, known for its distinctive addition that sets it apart from other regional varieties. This Midwestern delight hails from Indiana, where locals have embraced a surprising yet harmonious ingredient that elevates the traditional chili recipe: pasta. Unlike the more common inclusion of beans or the exclusive use of meat, Hoosier chili often incorporates elbow macaroni or spaghetti, transforming the dish into a hearty, satisfying meal that combines the warmth of chili with the heartiness of pasta. The addition of pasta not only adds bulk and texture but also absorbs the rich, flavorful sauces, ensuring every bite is a delightful blend of spices and savory goodness. This innovation reflects the Midwestern penchant for combining practicality with comfort, resulting in a dish that's both filling and flavorful. Hoosier chili maintains the classic elements of a traditional chili, such as ground beef, tomatoes, onions, and a medley of spices, but the pasta inclusion makes it a standout. This adaptation showcases the creativity of Hoosier cooks, who have successfully carved out a niche in the chili world by blending traditional elements with their own regional twist, creating a dish that resonates with locals and visitors alike.

The murky origins of Hoosier chili

An article in The Indy Star notes that the first recorded instance of Hoosier chili dates back to 1908, when an Indiana woman named E.C. Comer shared her chili recipe with a local newspaper. This was 14 years before the creation of the more widely known Cincinnati chili in 1922. Comer's recipe included "a 10-cent piece of boiling beef" and the contentious ingredient that sparks debates about chili: spaghetti. The exact moment and reason why macaroni noodles became the standard pasta for Hoosier chili remains uncertain, but it is believed that this substitution was a cost-effective way to make the dish more substantial during the Great Depression, catering to Midwesterners who were not used to the spiciness typical of Southwestern cuisine.

Today, numerous Hoosier chili recipes can be found online, with some food bloggers referring to it as "Hoosier chili soup" or "chili mac soup." There are also variations that use different pasta shapes, such as rotini, instead of elbow macaroni. While traditional beef chili enthusiasts may be taken aback by the inclusion of macaroni—or any type of noodle—this addition provides a pleasant balance of carbohydrates to a dish that is otherwise rich in protein. And remember, don’t dismiss it without giving it a try. You might discover that Hoosier chili is delicious enough to become a staple in your home-cooked meals, even if you choose to call it something other than "chili."

The Addition That Sets Hoosier Chili Apart From The Rest

The murky origins of Hoosier chili

Recommended

Next up