11 Flavored Coffee Brands That Use The Highest Quality Ingredients

Bones Coffee

Bones Coffee embodies the heartwarming spirit of a family success story that could easily serve as the backdrop for a 90s romantic comedy. Certified by the Rainforest Alliance, the company ensures that its coffee is socially, economically, and environmentally sustainable. Since its founding in 2015, Bones has introduced a range of innovative flavors, including Strawberry Cheesecake. Their lineup features seasonal favorites like Carrot Cake and the white chocolate-infused White Rabbit, alongside limited edition offerings inspired by pop culture, such as Tim Burton's The Pumpkin King. This diverse selection of unique flavors is truly impressive.

On the ingredient front, Bones Coffee maintains a positive profile; their ground and whole bean coffees are gluten-free and free from sugar and artificial sweeteners. The beans they use are low in acidity, allergen-free, and 100% Arabica, crafted with a blend of natural and artificial flavorings. While Bones Coffee does contain propylene glycol—an industry-standard additive deemed safe by the FDA—it has raised some concerns among consumers.

Overall, reviews are largely favorable, with coffee enthusiast Mrs. Brew praising the brand: "Regardless of the season, you can count on Bones Coffee Company for exceptional, high-quality flavored coffee. I've relished their pumpkin coffee for two consecutive years."

Joffrey's

One of the top spots to enjoy a cup of flavored coffee is in Tampa, Florida. Joffrey's Tea and Coffee Emporium launched its first location there in 1984, and its founder, Chris de Mezzo, who is also the self-proclaimed roast master, continues to be the "innovative force behind the 100+ coffee varieties available."

The selection of flavored coffees is truly impressive: Jamaican Me Crazy combines caramel, vanilla, and coffee liqueur; Angel's Kiss features a delightful blend of chocolate and coconut cream; and the beloved Toasted S'mores needs no introduction.

Dedicated fans of Joffrey's can also participate in the fun. The Tea and Coffee Emporium invites customer input each year through its Flavor Originator Contest, where you can suggest ingredients, name new brews, and rally votes to keep your favorites on the menu.

The company prioritizes sustainability, sourcing 100% high-quality Arabica beans from "ethically and responsibly farmed regions, where the environment is honored, and workers receive fair compensation." You can purchase your coffee in ground, whole bean, or cold brew formats, all boasting impressive credentials. The flavorings are gluten-free, sugar-free, and allergen-free, containing no calories at all. Additionally, their flavored coffees are free from eggs and dairy, making them suitable for vegans.

Coffee Beanery

Every coffee house on this list has opted for Arabica beans instead of Robusta as the foundation for their flavored coffees, and the reason is straightforward: Arabica beans offer superior taste. Coffee Beanery recognizes this more than most.

The first Coffee Beanery location opened its doors in 1976, long before the term "specialty coffee" became familiar to the American public. This assertion is not just an exaggeration; specialty coffee is a recognized industry term that, according to Origin Coffee, signifies that it "[h]as met the standards of excellence throughout every stage of the supply chain, from meticulous care of the crop grown, to harvesting and processing."

Today, Coffee Beanery operates over 100 stores across the United States, with an additional 20 locations internationally. When it comes to flavored coffee, Coffee Beanery has an impressive variety. Their offerings include a diverse selection of delightful blends such as Apricot Cake, Butter Pecan Ice Cream, and Chocolate Hazelnut Bon Bon, which are popular among customers, along with a few exclusive subscription-only treats like Frosted Carrot Cake.

Coffee Beanery takes pride in the way it crafts its uniquely named brews. As the brand explains, after roasting the beans to a light/medium level, the roasters "layer premium flavoring oils with the beans and mix them until they are perfectly blended," resulting in what they claim is "the most premium flavored coffee available."

Starbucks

Several brands on this list require little introduction, and none exemplify this more than Starbucks. As the leading name in the market, Starbucks has opted for a more straightforward approach compared to the often extravagant naming conventions found in flavored coffee brands. However, their selection remains quite impressive.

You can find all the usual options available: cold brew, instant coffee, pods, and ground coffee can be conveniently purchased from their website (though it's worth noting that whole bean flavored coffee is notably missing). Starbucks exclusively uses Arabica beans, but allergen information is specific to each product. Details about their unique blend of ingredients are limited, aside from their claim that their flavored coffees contain no artificial additives.

Despite this, customer reviews are largely favorable. For instance, Starbucks' Caramel Latte Premium Instant coffee boasts a rating of 4.6 based on 651 reviews. The Toasted Coconut Mocha also holds a 4.6-star rating, while their cold brew, naturally flavored Dark Chocolate Hazelnut, is impressively rated at 4.9 stars.

Nespresso

With a vast array of flavor choices, Nespresso can never truly establish a definitive "best of" list that everyone agrees on. Nevertheless, the brand enjoys a loyal following, celebrated for its commitment to sustainability and user-friendliness. If you can overlook the sometimes steep price, there's no doubt you'll be indulging in a premium experience.

All of Nespresso's blends are crafted from Arabica beans, and the company offers the option to select beans based on their country of origin through its World Explorations collection. Nespresso is transparent about the contents of each pod. According to their website, "The Nespresso capsules contain only freshly roasted and ground coffee, except for the flavored varieties (Vanilla Éclair, Caramel Créme Brûlée, Cocoa Truffle), which include natural flavors added to the fresh coffee."

Nespresso is also refreshingly open about its flavoring process. The flavors are introduced after grinding the coffee, using fine powders made from natural ingredients that serve as "a base component of the characterized flavor," and they assure customers that "They don't contain any food allergens."

Popular offerings like the Barista Creations Flavor Pack feature a delightful selection. The Vaniglia blend boasts sweet biscuit and cereal notes, the Chioccolatino is inspired by dark chocolate and made with all-natural flavors, while the classic Nocciola, rich in hazelnut, evokes the taste of high-quality praline.

Crazy Cups

At its founding, Crazy Cups embarked on a mission to capture the delight of trying a new ice cream flavor without the guilt of excess calories. Staying true to this vision, the brand provides a diverse selection of products, including hot chocolates, cappuccinos, vanilla shakes, and, of course, flavored coffees. Customers can purchase coffee either ground or in pod form, with the option of a one-time buy or a subscription service for added savings.

With an overwhelming variety of flavors, it's impossible to list them all, let alone sample each one. Notable favorites include the popular Chocolate Raspberry Truffle, the highly-rated Decaf Frosted Oatmeal Cookie, and the irresistibly delicious Buttery Caramel Popcorn coffee pods.

Regarding ingredients, Crazy Cups maintains a serious commitment to quality. The Arabica beans are sourced globally, and no sweeteners are added to their flavored coffees. Additionally, Crazy Cups is nut-free and certified kosher, and it also offers organic options through its Eko Cups sub-brand.

Barnie's Coffee Tea and Co

Barnie's launched its inaugural store in Winter Park, Florida, in 1980, following some experimentation with Peruvian coffee plants that led to the creation of its signature flavor. In 1994, the company introduced Santa's White Christmas, which quickly became a favorite among customers, who embraced what Barnie's later characterized as "a delightful blend of toasty vanilla, coconut, and caramel."

Over the years, a variety of other blends have adorned its unique packaging, including English Slated Toffee, a mix of caramel, maple, pecan, and cinnamon known as Cool Café Blues, and the naturally flavored Southern Pecan. All of Barnie's coffee beans are 100% Arabica, free from sugar, gluten, and nuts, and contain fewer than five calories per eight-ounce cup. However, the flavorings used are both natural and artificial, which means Barnie's is one of the few brands on this list that does not carry the all-natural label. Nevertheless, customer feedback remains positive, with Santa's White Christmas earning an impressive average rating of 4.79 stars from approximately 609 reviews.

Grounds and Hounds

Grounds and Hounds is among the companies offering a subscription service, and creating an account with them comes with additional perks. Their specialty coffees are not only organic and eco-friendly, but the company also dedicates 20% of its profits to support animal rescue organizations that care for abandoned dogs and puppies.

Founded in 2013 after the owner adopted a Dalmatian from a rescue shelter, the company started with just six coffee varieties and has since grown to offer dozens. Customers can choose from flavored coffees available in both ground and pod formats, including seasonal delights like the fragrant Blueberry Crumble, as well as year-round favorites such as Glazed Donut and Brownie A La Mode.

The quality of their products is evident; the Arabica beans are sourced from regions renowned for their premium ingredients and are roasted in small batches to enhance flavor. Their flavored coffees are vegan, free from sugar and gluten, and several decaffeinated options are also available for direct purchase on their website.

With thousands of five-star reviews, Grounds and Hounds has established itself as a leading producer of flavored coffee in the market. Additionally, the knowledge that each sip contributes to the care of needy dogs is a compelling incentive for animal lovers.

One Great Coffee

One Great Coffee has discovered a straightforward recipe for exceptional coffee that is hard to dispute. They believe that outstanding coffee should be fresh, sourced from the finest regions worldwide, preserve its flavor through variety, and provide a wide selection to cater to diverse tastes.

Owners Donna and Mike's passion for discovering the best small-batch roasters of single-origin beans led them to establish One Great Cup later in life. Now in their 60s, the company’s modest beginnings are still fresh in their minds. Alongside its gourmet, organic, and micro-lot coffees, the website currently features over 140 different flavored coffees, with new options being added regularly.

Each flavor is available in regular, decaf, whole bean, or ground forms, and their 100% grade one Arabica beans are roasted to order and shipped the same day. Customer reviews are overwhelmingly positive, with five-star favorites like Italian Chocolate and Golden Pecan alongside intriguing options such as Sinful Delight, Swiss Chocolate Bunny, and Cupid's Kiss. Each flavor contains fewer than five calories per 8-ounce serving and is guaranteed to be of gourmet quality.

Death Wish Coffee

With a name like Death Wish, it’s easy to assume this is just another coffee brand focused on gimmicks rather than taste. However, that assumption would be incorrect. Death Wish offers some of the finest USDA certified Fair-Trade coffee available. The company carefully sources its beans from top growing regions, including Peru, Guatemala, Honduras, and Ethiopia, and conducts a thorough farm-to-cup evaluation to ensure that only the highest quality products make it to store shelves.

Among the typical offerings of modern small-batch roasters, you’ll discover some standout options in the flavored coffee category. Classic favorites like Vanilla, available in both ground and pod forms, sit alongside unique blends such as Almond Afterlife, Chocolate Hazelnut, and the blueberry coffee cake-inspired Blue and Buried.

While Death Wish may have a more limited selection compared to some other brands, their dedication to quality ingredients speaks volumes. Their coffee is organic and completely free from artificial flavorings. Additionally, the fact that their coffee was deemed worthy enough to be sent to outer space via the International Space Station highlights the high regard in which they are held.

Omar Coffee

Omar Coffee has been roasting beans since 1937, making it the oldest coffee company on this list by a significant margin. Located in Newington, Connecticut, Omar Coffee was established by John Costas, a native of Constantinople who emigrated to pursue the American dream. Now, four generations later, the mission of Omar Coffee—to "source premium green coffee beans, slow roast them to perfection, and consistently provide superior freshness and personalized service to all customers"—remains unchanged.

What has evolved, however, is the range of options available to consumers. The product lineup features iconic flavors such as Chocolate Cherry, Pistachio, and Toasted Almond. Each year, limited-edition seasonal flavors are introduced, and for those who find it difficult to choose, a flavor of the month option is available to help simplify the selection process.

Customer reviews are consistently positive, and quality control measures are stringent. Like all companies on this list, Omar Coffee exclusively uses 100% Arabica beans sourced from over twenty countries worldwide. Its coffee is vegan—except for the Cinnamon Sticky Bun flavor—and every variety can be purchased as a decaf option, with the choice of whole bean or ground delivery. Additionally, several flavors are available in single-serve K-cups.

How we assessed the quality of these flavored coffees

We examined the ingredient lists of each brand for an overabundance of additives, colorings, or added sugars. We verified that the companies utilize Arabica beans instead of Robusta and cross-referenced this information with favorable user reviews. Whenever applicable, we highlighted allergen warnings, confirmed dietary restrictions, and filtered for nutritional details concerning added sugars and artificial flavorings.